Heaven Mayhem Dupes: Best Earring Finds Under $50

Accessories
Written By Lily

This blog post may contain affiliate links. I may earn a small commission for any purchases made through these links. Click here for the disclosure statement.

Heaven Mayhem earrings are taking over my feed with their irresistible, vintage-inspired designs. Founded in 2023 in Los Angeles by the visionary Pia Mance, Heaven Mayhem has quickly become synonymous with elevating the modern capsule wardrobe. And with the rise of the 80s jewelry trend, this rapidly growing brand is definitely one to watch for pieces that pay homage to the decade, reimagined for today’s style-conscious woman.

Among Heaven Mayhem’s bestsellers, you’ll find bold, antique-inspired studs that are oh-so-sophisticated. Each piece is available in silver, gold or mixed metal finishes. Plus, the brand offers a selection of watches, belts, necklaces and even brooches, all featuring their signature vintage-style hardware.

It’s no wonder these pieces have captured the hearts of your favorite fashion influences. Hailey Bieber, Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Matilda Djerf, and Lori Harvey—the biggest "it-girls" are all obsessed. And honestly, who wouldn’t be?

But let’s be honest—while the allure of Heaven Mayhem is undeniable, the price tag can make even the most stylish among us hesitate. If you’re anything like me, you love a good statement earring but wouldn’t mind finding a more budget-friendly option. That’s why I’ve scoured the web to bring you some of the best Heaven Mayhem dupes that look just as chic without breaking the bank. For those iconic 80s silhouettes, I’ve got you covered.

Let’s dive into these stunning alternatives to refresh your jewelry collection this season—without the steep cost.

Shop Vintage-Inspired Earrings

Heaven Mayhem Alternatives

Mini Knot Earrings

 
 
 
 

Tabi Earrings

West Angel Jewelry

Paige Earrings

$35 on Etsy
 
 
 

Wind Earrings

 
 
 

Wing Earrings

 
 
 

Ribbed Earrings

West Angel Jewelry

Santorini Earrings

$35 on Etsy
 
 

Tri Earrings

West Angel Jewelry

Brooke Earrings

$35 on Etsy
 
 

Noir Earrings

 
8 Other Reasons

Lady Earrings

$42 on Revolve
 

Shell Earrings

 
 

Gigi Earrings

 

How to Shop Vintage Earrings

Shopping for vintage earrings is a great way to achieve the on-trend look of Heaven Mayhem earrings without breaking the bank. Here are some tips on where and what to shop for to get the same 80s-style earrings:

1. Browse Online Marketplaces

Websites like Etsy, eBay, and Poshmark are literal treasure troves for vintage jewelry. Search for terms like "80s earrings" or "vintage gold studs" to find pieces that resemble the big and bold designs of Heaven Mayhem. You can score vintage earrings at incredibly affordable prices too—while browsing on eBay, I found some stunning pairs under $10! Perfect if you want to try the trend without splurging.

2. Visit Local Thrift Stores

Thrift stores, flea markets and antique shops often carry unique, one-of-a-kind earrings that you won’t find anywhere else. The selection can be hit or miss, but the best finds often take a little patience and some luck!

3. Check Out Estate Sales

Estate sales can be goldmines for vintage jewelry. These events often feature collections from older generations, making it possible to snag high-quality, vintage earrings at a fraction of their original price. Keep an eye out for sales in affluent neighborhoods, where you're more likely to find well-maintained pieces.

4. Shop Your Mom’s Jewelry Collection

One of the best—and often free—places to find vintage earrings with a similar vibe to Heaven Mayhem is right at home in your mom’s (or grandmother’s) jewelry box.

Many women hold onto pieces from past decades, especially from the 80s and 90s, which might include statement styles that directly inspired Heaven Mayhem’s coveted designs.

An old pair of earrings becomes an instant heirloom with a personal history that makes wearing them even more special. Plus, borrowing or inheriting jewelry from your mom is the ultimate in sustainable fashion—it’s a way to explore trends without contributing to new consumption, all while keeping these cherished pieces in the family. It’s a win-win.

5. Know Your Brands

Familiarize yourself with OG jewelry brands that were popular in the past, such as Trifari, Monet, Napier, Kenneth Jay Lane, and Sarah Coventry. These brands produced high-quality, stylish pieces that are still accessible today. Their designs often feature the same 80s details that make Heaven Mayhem earrings so appealing.

6. Be Patient and Persistent

Finding the perfect pair of earrings secondhand can take time, so be patient and persistent in your search. Set alerts on your favorite online marketplaces for specific keywords, and regularly visit your local thrift stores to stay on top of new arrivals. You’ll find your new favorite pair of vintage earrings in no time!

Shop Vintage-Inspired Earrings

Finding the perfect dupe for those stunning Heaven Mayhem earrings doesn’t have to be a challenge. With so many affordable options out there, you can get the same vintage-inspired 80s vibe without the hefty price tag. Give these picks a try, and let me know your favorites in the comments!

I’m personally loving the Tabi earrings—simple, square and so chic! If I don’t find a similar vintage option, I’ll definitely be shopping the alternatives on this list.

Which Heaven Mayhem earrings are your favorite? Let me know in the comments below.

You May Also Like

Lily

By Lily

Previous

16 Best Online Designer Outlets to Save Money on Your Wardrobe
Next

How to Create a Makeup Capsule Collection